← Back to home

Document A-5911

AI Analysis

Summary: The speaker reflects on the defense team's failure to inform the court about potentially exculpatory information, suggesting it was a mistake rather than a strategic decision. They argue that the team's actions were not a deliberate strategy, but rather a case of 'dropping the ball.' The speaker implies that this failure led to a lengthy trial that may need to be repeated.
Significance: This document potentially reveals a critical analysis of the defense team's actions during a trial, suggesting they may have been ineffective or negligent in their representation.
Key Topics: Ineffective assistance of counsel Failure to disclose information to the court Trial strategy vs. negligence
Key People:
  • The Brune firm lawyers - Defense attorneys whose actions are being scrutinized

Full Text

CAC3PARC 1 themselves we failed the Court. I have said to myself a 2 hundred times, it is so easy the next morning or even that 3 afternoon to walk back in and say to the judge, Judge, we 4 think -- we don't really believe this, for a variety of 5 reasons, but you should know the following. That she has the 6 same name, there is other information here, and whatever your 7 Honor wants to do with it, we don't think it's her, but we 8 would be foolish if we didn't bring this to your attention. 9 I think what happened to the Brune firm was after this 10 revelation, they said to themselves oh God, we really did drop 11 the ball. But dropping the ball is ineffectiveness. Dropping 12 the ball to me is not strategy. 13 Look, if your Honor looks at that conduct, and I know, 14 and I say this respectfully, I know how much that conduct eats 15 at the Court because it's wrong, and the result of it is a very 16 long trial in this courtroom has to be done again. But, I also 17 don't think that one looks at it and says ah-ha, there was a 18 strategy going on. 19 I think the lawyers thought to themselves that the 20 Court is going to be very disappointed in us if it realizes 21 that we didn't come forward. Right. If it realizes we took 22 for an answer it can't be her, when investigation or telling 23 the Court was the better course. 24 If the Court concludes that that conduct is so 25 egregious that circumstantially it proves strategy, I'm not SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. (212) 805-0300